Debt-driven inclusiveness
By: Randy David
Philippine Daily Inquirer
2:56 am | Thursday, May 3rd, 2012
Waiting in line for my turn at a Landbank ATM in the UP campus the other
day, I started to fret at seeing the queue wasn't moving. Two women were
hogging the machine and serially withdrawing money. They shuffled what
looked like a deck of plastic cards while routinely consulting a small
notebook.
"Wow," I told the person next to me, hoping the card-shufflers would
overhear, "I've never seen anyone with so many bank accounts." Wryly,
she said, "It's the 30th, that's why. They're collectors." Only then did
I realize how terribly mired in debt our government workers are. I've
recently learned that as many as 80 percent of them have reached the
maximum (sagad na) they can take out, which means their monthly
take-home pay must not fall below P5,000. But, most likely, they have
also borrowed against this remaining amount, thus leaving their ATM
cards with the loan sharks.
Viewed from this frame, one can appreciate the significance of the
government's decision to release, ahead of time, the last tranche of the
staggered salary increase for the country's 1.5 million government
employees. It puts much-needed cash into the hands of families that are
not only without savings, but are so indebted that they must borrow for
their daily needs. This final increase raises the minimum pay (salary
grade 1) for government workers to P9,000, excluding allowances. This is
very low compared to what businessmen and professionals in our society
earn, and what government workers in prosperous countries are paid. But
it compares favorably with what workers in the private sector make.
Minimum wage by itself, however, is not a good gauge of the condition of
the working class. Increases in the price of food, utilities and
transportation can quickly wipe out any wage increase. This makes
inflation the biggest enemy of labor. More than legislated wage
increases, I prefer to see social redistribution take the form of
concrete improvements in the quality and accessibility of basic
education, health services and mass housing.
But there is another side to the situation of the poor that interests me
as a sociologist. And that is the effect of a consumerist culture on our
people's daily life. We pride ourselves in having one of the highest
mobile phone penetrations in the world. Indeed we like to think of
ourselves as the texting capital of the world, as if that were a measure
of development. But how much real productive use do we put this amazing
technology to? My guess is not much. Yet mobile phones are now regarded
as basic necessity. I've seen people scrimp on food just to buy phone
load. They feel miserable when they cannot text or call, as if all
worthy human interaction depended on the cell phone.
But the mobile phone is just the most visible emblem of our consumerist
way of life. The capital of modern consumerism is the shopping mall.
Whereas in developed countries, the growing popularity of Internet
shopping is putting big and fully-staffed stores out of business, the
opposite is taking place here. Our shopping malls are getting bigger,
and their reach has become so wide they have integrated small-town
grocery and sari-sari stores as their satellites. It is not surprising
that the growth of the mall economy has followed the same trajectory as
the instant prosperity created by overseas work. These malls would not
be where they are today without OFW remittances. And where the malls
are, the fast-food chains cannot be far behind. It is this
democratization of consumption that fosters the illusion of
inclusiveness in our otherwise highly stratified society.
One would think that a country that earns about $20 billion annually
from its overseas workers would be, sooner or later, well-positioned to
capitalize its own long-term growth. But we've been sending out workers
for nearly four decades now. The growth in income has not transformed
Filipino families into savers. It has only made them consume more. As
their incomes rise, so have their needs multiplied. Sadly, it is not
just their lifestyles that have changed, but also their moral intuitions
about what constitutes a worthwhile life. Nowadays few think twice about
leaving their young children behind in the hope of earning more abroad.
Much of the evidence for this sea change in our way of life is
anecdotal. One wishes someone like Daniel Kahneman, 2002 Nobel Prize
winner in the economic sciences, could do a study of how the intuitions
that currently shape Filipino lives defy everything presumed by the
"rational agent model"—maybe something along the lines of a psychology
of stupidity, to which all of us, regardless of social class or
education, are susceptible.
I have a neighbor in Bataan who has been bugging me for the longest time
to help him get a job in an ocean-going liner. He hasn't been jobless at
home, but he thinks he's not earning enough to support his growing
family. I managed to set him up for a job test with a crewing company
owned by an acquaintance. A high school graduate, this man is a fine
all-round carpenter, but twice he failed the oral interview in English.
From a local job that engaged him for a year, he had netted P20,000 in
savings. He put in a portion as down payment for a motorbike, but the
monthly amortization soon ate up all the money he had. After five
months, he had to return the bike, forfeiting every cent he had paid. He
has asked me again to endorse his application for an overseas job. I
strongly advised him to stay in a job which will not take him away so
long from his family. I don't think his case is unusual. Like many, he
suffers from an exaggerated view of the benefits of working abroad.
public.lives@gmail.com
--
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CARLOS ANI - International Microfinance Consultant - SEEDFINANCE Corporation Chairman
Mailing address: PO Box 90 UPLB Los Banos Laguna, Philippines 4031
Emails: carlosani@gmail.com , carlosani@seedfinance.net
Landline Phone: +63495010127 (PLDT)
Cellphone Numbers: +639152919580 (Globe) and +639328590859 (Sun)
Websites:
CARLOSANI.COM - http://www.carlosani.com
DEVJOBS - http://www.devjobsmail.com
PHILDEVFINANCE - http://phildevfinance.posterous.com
My News Clippings - http://www.myclipps.posterous.com
Family website - http://www.anifamily.net
SEEDFINANCE Corporation - http://www.seedfinance.net
Skype name: carlosaniph
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
***********
This message is intended only for the named recipient and may contain confidential, proprietary or legally privileged information. No confidentiality or privilege is waived or lost by any misdirected transmission. If you received this message in error, please notify us immediately by telephone at +63495010127 and immediately delete this message from your system. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not use, disclose, distribute or copy any part of this message. Thank you.
***********
